The Harley Quinn and Joker Relationship: History, Comics and Mad Love

Updated

The Harley Quinn and Joker relationship is the oldest part of her story and the part writers have spent thirty years taking apart. It was never a romance. This page follows its history through the comics and the screen, from the first episode to the break.

Lithograph-style illustration of two commedia half-masks lying apart on a plank floor, one cracked, beside an open trunk
Modern illustration after commedia dell’arte prints

Act I

How the Harley Quinn and Joker relationship began

In the original version Harleen Quinzel is a young psychiatrist at Arkham Asylum. She asks to work with the Joker, and in their sessions he tells her stories about a hard childhood and a cruel father, designed to win her sympathy. They work: she falls for him, helps him escape and takes on the name Harley Quinn.

From the first episode, "Joker’s Favor" in 1992, the cartoon plays the pair for laughs, but the pattern of the Harley Quinn and Joker relationship is already there. He gives the orders and takes the credit; she takes the blame when a plan goes wrong. The joke is that she does not see it. The writers did.

Act II

Mad Love, the comic that named the problem

The Batman Adventures: Mad Love by Paul Dini and Bruce Timm, cover-dated February 1994, is the Mad Love comic most of the later history starts from. It tells the Arkham origin in full and then shows what living with the Joker means: when Harley comes close to beating Batman with one of his own ideas, he flies into a rage and throws her out of a window.

Batman, of all people, is the one who tells her the truth: the sad stories were lies, told to whoever was listening. Harley survives the fall, lies in a hospital bed, decides it was her own fault, and forgives the Joker the moment he sends her a flower. The Mad Love comic won the 1994 Eisner Award for Best Single Issue, and The New Batman Adventures adapted it as an episode in 1999.

Act III

Joker and Harley Quinn history, step by step

Seven dates mark the Joker and Harley Quinn history on page and screen, from her first episode as his assistant in 1992 to the 2020 film that opens after the breakup.

The relationship across comics and screen
YearStoryWhat happens
1992Joker’s Favor (TV)Harley appears as the Joker's assistant, played as comic relief.
1993Harley and Ivy (TV)She leaves him for a while and teams up with Poison Ivy, who calls the relationship what it is.
1994Mad Love (comic)The origin, and the window: the abuse becomes the subject of the story.
1999Mad Love (TV)The New Batman Adventures adapts the comic.
2013Harley Quinn (comics)Conner and Palmiotti write her on her own, with the Joker in the past.
2019Harley Quinn (TV)The first season of the animated series is built around her break from him.
2020Birds of Prey (film)The film opens after the breakup and follows her life without him.

Act IV

The comics years between Mad Love and the break

In October 1999 Paul Dini wrote Batman: Harley Quinn, the one-shot that brought her from the cartoon into the main DC comics, and a monthly Harley Quinn series followed in 2000. Those comics kept the pattern of the cartoon: long stretches of independence, then a return to the Joker that always ended badly for her.

In 2009 Dini put her into Gotham City Sirens, a team-up with Poison Ivy and Catwoman in which she spent long stretches without the Joker. After DC relaunched its line in 2011 she joined the Suicide Squad, and the abuse in her past was shown more directly than in the cartoon. By the time Conner and Palmiotti took over in 2013, the question was no longer whether she would leave him, but what she would do once she had.

Act V

Harley Quinn in the comics after the break

For years after Mad Love the comics kept sending her back to him, and the Harley Quinn and Joker relationship stayed the engine of her stories. The 2013 series by Amanda Conner and Jimmy Palmiotti changed that: Harley moves to Brooklyn, runs her own life and her own team, and the Joker becomes a figure from her past. When later stories bring him back, she is the one who says no.

The friendship with Poison Ivy grew in the same years. Ivy is the character who first told Harley that she deserved better, in the animated series, and in later comics and in the 2019 animated series the two become a couple. The Joker and Harley Quinn history is the part of her life she leaves; Ivy is part of the life she builds.

Act VI

Why the Harley Quinn and Joker relationship still matters

The Harley Quinn and Joker relationship stays popular, and sometimes it is sold as a love story on posters and costumes. The stories themselves say the opposite. Mad Love shows how a manipulative partner works: charm, lies about the past, blame, a gift after the harm. Later stories show what leaving looks like and how long it can take.

Read in order, the Joker and Harley Quinn history in comics and on screen makes one long argument for walking away. For the quotes that trace the same change, from the cheerful early lines to "My fault... I didn't get the joke", see the collected Harley Quinn quotes.

Finale

Questions about Joker and Harley

Is the Harley Quinn and Joker relationship abusive?

Yes. From Mad Love (1994) on, the stories show the Joker manipulating, belittling and hurting her. Later stories are about her leaving him.

Where is their origin told?

In the Mad Love comic by Paul Dini and Bruce Timm, cover-dated February 1994, adapted as an episode of The New Batman Adventures in 1999.

When do Harley and the Joker break up?

In several versions: in the 2013 comics she lives on her own, the 2019 animated series builds its first season around the break, and Birds of Prey (2020) starts after the breakup.

Are Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy a couple?

In later comics and in the 2019 Harley Quinn animated series, yes. Their friendship goes back to the 1993 episode "Harley and Ivy".

Who created Harley and the relationship?

Paul Dini and Bruce Timm, who created Harley for Batman: The Animated Series in 1992.

Sources: The Batman Adventures: Mad Love, Wikipedia; Eisner Award for Best Single Issue, Wikipedia; Harley Quinn publication history, Wikipedia; How Harley Quinn Got Her Groove Back, DC; Harley Quinn's journey away from the Joker, Syfy.

↑